Home > The Importance of...
About this Author
Ernest Miller Ernest Miller pursues research and writing on cyberlaw, intellectual property, and First Amendment issues. Mr. Miller attended the U.S. Naval Academy before attending Yale Law School, where he was president and co-founder of the Law and Technology Society, and founded the technology law and policy news site LawMeme. He is a fellow of the Information Society Project at Yale Law School. Ernest Miller's blog postings can also be found @
Copyfight
LawMeme

Listen to the weekly audio edition on IT Conversations:
The Importance Of ... Law and IT.

Feel free to contact me about articles, websites and etc. you think I may find of interest. I'm also available for consulting work and speaking engagements. Email: ernest.miller 8T gmail.com

Amazon Honor System Click Here to Pay Learn More

LINKS
freedom_sake_md_2.PNG Balkinization
bIPlog
bricoleur
Cairns Blog: Beth Noveck
Copyfight
Copyfighter's Musings
Copyright Blog
Chris Cohen
Dan Gillmor's eJournal
DigitalConsumer.org
Displacement of Concepts
DTM :<|
Freedom to Tinker
Furdlog
GigaLaw.com News
GrepLaw
infoAnarchy
Infothought
Internet Law Program Blog
Joe Gratz
Law School Discussion
LawMeme
Lessig Blog
Matt Rolls a Hoover
Napsterization
David Opterbeck
Politech
Scobleizer
SIVACRACY.NET
Slashdot
Susan Crawford Blog
Unlimited Freedom
< A Legally Inclined Weblog >

RECENT ENTRIES
RECENT COMMENTS [xml]
› Jonna Hicks on
Salsa Verde

› Miles Cleveland on
Kitchen Academy - Course II - Day 16

› Keagan Sousa on
Kitchen Academy - Course I - Day 14

› Jordan Reichert on
Kitchen Academy - Course I - Day 18

› Keagan Sousa on
Kitchen Academy - Course I - Day 14

› Derek Sullivan on
Kitchen Academy - Course II - Day 7

Recent Trackbacks
› jeu casino gratuit:
jeu casino gratuit

› casino en francais:
casino en francais

› Internet and Information Technology Security - eLamb:
To Dan Glickman

› Blogs - Steven Shelton's Blog - GLOAMING.us:
Federal Judges: More Intelligent than Creationists

› The world according to SComps:
Penna going to hell! Robertson confirms it.

› Blog For mis111, Section 1, Group 080:
Coca Cola Threatens Photographer With Lawsuit


Subscribe with Bloglines

Creative Commons License
All text in this web log is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
In the Boston area?: Join us on June 11 for Startups and the Cloud, a free event on cloud computing with insights from Intuit founder Scott Cook and others


The Importance of...


July 09, 2004
Are the Opponents of the INDUCE Act (IICA) Claiming that the Sky is Falling?Email This EntryPrint This Entry
Posted by Ernest Miller

The Motley Fool calls opponents of the Inducing Infringment of Copyrights Act (IICA, née INDUCE Act) the "Chicken Little crowd" (Will Congress Kill the iPod?):

What the bill would do is amend existing copyright law to allow lawsuits against those who "intentionally induce" copyright infringement. It would be nearly impossible for a reasonable person -- and that is the standard used in the bill -- to decide that an iPod is a tool for intentional violation of copyright. Ditto a pay-per-download service with copy-protection schemes. [italics in original]
Well, I'm so relieved. After spending millions to get through a jury trial, established technologies would likely survive. We can be sure that the reasonable person would have voted to save the VCR (in the early years when they were expensive and not widely used), what with Valenti (a reasonable guy himself) telling the reasonable man that the VCR was a vicious serial killer designed by the Japanese to assault Hollywood. Oh, and systems with copy-protection schemes would be allowed to thrive. Why, that is just dandy.

Actually, however, this column does make a very good point, one I've made on the Pho List. If the INDUCE Act actually becomes law, it is highly improbable that Apple would be sued over the iPod. Yes, a plausible case could be made against Apple: EFF's Mock INDUCE Act Lawsuit. However, realistically, the RIAA has made its peace with Apple and would not sue them. That's a bit of the problem with the Save the iPod campaign. The website asks "Is the iPod Really at Risk?" and answers "Yes!" Well, no. It isn't the iPod that is at risk, it is the small company's non-DRM'd wireless iPod clone that is at risk. The biggest threat is to the innovative next-generation iPod from some company that no one has heard of yet that the RIAA will quash long before it can sell millions of units and make us all wonder how we survived without one.

That's a harder story to sell and make bumper stickers for. On the other hand, by claiming a need to "Save the iPod," you run into a problem when people say, "don't be ridiculous, Apple isn't going to be sued," because they're right. Your "Save the iPod" campaign will certainly not look credible if Apple is supporting the other side (they certainly haven't come out against the INDUCE Act yet). As a consequence, it is going to be a little harder, now, to convince the readers of the Motley Fool that they should oppose the INDUCE Act.

In other INDUCE Act news, Digital-Lifestyles.info, has a brief piece on the IICA (Senate Moves to Outlaw P2P Applications):

The sponsors of this bill are being blinkered into a view that is entirely concerned with the profits of one group – the music industry. The backers of the Induce act are rallying towards just one group at the moment, because that's where the money is.
I have to disagree. The IICA backers are also rallying for the MPAA and BSA.

UPDATE

Audio/Video Revolution does a short straight-up story on the issue (New Bill Suggests Apple Could Get Sued For What People Do With Their iPods).


Category: INDUCE Act


COMMENTS

There are no comments posted yet for this entry.


TRACKBACKS
TrackBack URL: http://www.corante.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-pcorso.cgi/3463
More Inductees To INDUCE ACT Stupidity from Get Real Ernest Miller continues his indefagitable invective around the fools (in this case, The Motley Fools) who really don't get why the INDUCE ACT is dangerous. The flapdoodle about the iPod being at risk is really not the point: Ernest Miller[from... [Read More]

Tracked on July 9, 2004 01:46 PM

INDUCE Act (IICA) Press Roundup - 29 July 2004 from The Importance of... I'm not sure what triggered it, but there is a slew of coverage of the Inducing Infringement of Copyrights Act (IICA, née INDUCE Act) today. Sen. Orrin Hatch's hometown newspaper, the Salt Lake Tribune runs an article that looks at... [Read More]

Tracked on July 29, 2004 04:02 PM

Higher Education Groups Oppose INDUCE Act (IICA) from The Importance of... The Daily Texan reports that the Inducing Infringement of Copyrights Act (IICA, née INDUCE Act) has raised the ire of several higher education organizations (Bill proposed to strengthen copyright laws). The article also has a bizarre quote from one of... [Read More]

Tracked on August 2, 2004 05:05 PM




POST A COMMENT
Name:

Email:

URL:

Comments:

Remember personal info?



EMAIL THIS ENTRY TO A FRIEND
Email this entry to:

Your email address:

Message (optional):




RELATED ENTRIES