Home > The Importance of...
About this Author
Ernest Miller Ernest Miller pursues research and writing on cyberlaw, intellectual property, and First Amendment issues. Mr. Miller attended the U.S. Naval Academy before attending Yale Law School, where he was president and co-founder of the Law and Technology Society, and founded the technology law and policy news site LawMeme. He is a fellow of the Information Society Project at Yale Law School. Ernest Miller's blog postings can also be found @

Listen to the weekly audio edition on IT Conversations:
The Importance Of ... Law and IT.

Feel free to contact me about articles, websites and etc. you think I may find of interest. I'm also available for consulting work and speaking engagements. Email: ernest.miller 8T gmail.com

Amazon Honor System Click Here to Pay Learn More

freedom_sake_md_2.PNG Balkinization
Cairns Blog: Beth Noveck
Copyfighter's Musings
Copyright Blog
Chris Cohen
Dan Gillmor's eJournal
Displacement of Concepts
DTM :<|
Freedom to Tinker
GigaLaw.com News
Internet Law Program Blog
Joe Gratz
Law School Discussion
Lessig Blog
Matt Rolls a Hoover
David Opterbeck
Susan Crawford Blog
Unlimited Freedom
< A Legally Inclined Weblog >

› Jonna Hicks on
Salsa Verde

› Miles Cleveland on
Kitchen Academy - Course II - Day 16

› Keagan Sousa on
Kitchen Academy - Course I - Day 14

› Jordan Reichert on
Kitchen Academy - Course I - Day 18

› Keagan Sousa on
Kitchen Academy - Course I - Day 14

› Derek Sullivan on
Kitchen Academy - Course II - Day 7

Recent Trackbacks
› jeu casino gratuit:
jeu casino gratuit

› casino en francais:
casino en francais

› Internet and Information Technology Security - eLamb:
To Dan Glickman

› Blogs - Steven Shelton's Blog - GLOAMING.us:
Federal Judges: More Intelligent than Creationists

› The world according to SComps:
Penna going to hell! Robertson confirms it.

› Blog For mis111, Section 1, Group 080:
Coca Cola Threatens Photographer With Lawsuit

Subscribe with Bloglines

Creative Commons License
All text in this web log is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
In the Pipeline: Don't miss Derek Lowe's excellent commentary on drug discovery and the pharma industry in general at In the Pipeline

The Importance of...

August 31, 2004
XM Radio's Stockholm SyndromeEmail This EntryPrint This Entry
Posted by Ernest Miller

Well, it is official. According to C|Net News, XM Radio has withdrawn their PC hardware version from the market as a response to the software known as NeroSoft TimeTrax, which permitted people to record from XM Radio to MP3 (XM Radio pulls PC hardware amid piracy concerns). TimeTrax has previously been featured here on Hatch's Hit List (Hatch's Hit List #30 - XM Radio to MP3).

Interestingly, according to the article, pulling the hardware off the market was not done at the behest of the RIAA:

"We are very concerned about a variety of technologies that essentially transform performances into music libraries," RIAA spokesman Steve Marks said. "We have communicated our concerns to XM and other broadcasters and Webcasters, (and told them) that we'd like to work together with them to address technologies that hijack these performances."

Marks said the RIAA wasn't behind the discontinuation of the PCR.

"We've raised the concern generally," he said. "They've obviously decided to take this action on their own. We've identified for them the potential problems."

Sounds like Stockholm Syndrome to me:
The Stockholm syndrome is a psychological state in which the victims of a kidnapping, or persons detained against their free will - prisoners - develop a relationship with their captor(s). This solidarity can sometimes become a real complicity, with prisoners actually helping the captors to achieve their goals or to escape police.

Educated Guesswork (Death to XM TiVo):

OK, I can totally understand the objection that people will use this to build a local library of songs--not that I think that should be illegal, but I understand it--but this last paragraph is, as far as I can tell, total nonsense. The gating factor in song availability over KaZaA is unlikely to be the ability to get a ripped version of the song. It's not like there's any shortage of consumers with Britney Spears CDs and CD-ROM drives. In fact, I would expect the availability if this sort of technology to decrease the amount of file sharing by making it easier to collect a library of known-to-be-correct songs.
Indeed, and even if your rip the songs, won't you still be paying subscription fees?

Techdirt (Is XM Bending Over Backwards To Make Satellite Radio Less Useful?):

It's quite a world when it's considered a problem that someone has made your service more useful. The note at Broadband Reports also claims that XM is considering removing USB ports from future equipment for the same reason. Both of these seem unconfirmed at the moment, so it would be nice if there were some real confirmation on either rumor. However, the satellite radio business is in a tough position. For all the success they've been claiming in signing up customers, they're nowhere near profitability. Their capital costs are incredibly high, and the thing they need, more than anything else, is more subscribers. Shutting down tools that make their offering more compelling just means they're making their job that much more difficult.

Category: Tools

PrivacyHound on August 31, 2004 04:53 AM writes...

One of the stunning things in he case of TimeTrax is that it only records the analog output of the XM receiver yet the industry acts like it records perfect copies. This degraded signal is clearly the kind of home recording that is permitted by radio listeners. Since TimeTrax does not record perfect serial copies, the industry over reaction clearly shows that the industry does not support existing analog copy usage. Because TimeTrax is a recording of an analog signal, and since the Grokster decision narrowed contributory infringement XM can only sue TimeTrax for violating the EULA. Even that is a stretch.

Permalink to Comment

TrackBack URL: http://www.corante.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-pcorso.cgi/4373
They didn't get the memo from Chromatic Musings The RIAA is all unhappy about a Canadian inventor's software that allows him to record XM transmissions and play them back later. Sounds sneakily like a VCR, huh? It's almost as if Sony v. Betamax didn't happen.... A spokesman for... [Read More]

Tracked on August 31, 2004 04:03 AM

Blawger Bowl from Loosely Coupled // Tim Marman's Weblog [Read More]

Tracked on August 31, 2004 04:06 AM

Blawger Bowl from Loosely Coupled // Tim Marman's Weblog [Read More]

Tracked on August 31, 2004 04:07 AM





Remember personal info?

Email this entry to:

Your email address:

Message (optional):